In the past how I outline a novel, my novel
I have started novels without an outline. I have started novels with a thirty-page outline. Both times, I ended up in the same place: somewhere in the middle of chapter seven, staring at a scene that refused to move, wondering where I had made the wrong turn.
The outline, when I had one, told me what should happen next. My character disagreed. She stood in the middle of the scene I had planned for her and simply would not do the thing. Not because she was being difficult. Because the thing I had planned was not true to who she had become in the sixty pages since I wrote the outline.
That is the problem with most outlining advice. It treats the story as something that exists before you write it something to be discovered, mapped, and then executed. But novels do not work that way. Characters become themselves in the writing. The story finds its shape as you move through it. An outline that does not allow for that is not a map. It is a cage.
What I want to show you here is a different kind of outline. One that gives you enough structure to move forward with confidence, but stays flexible enough to grow alongside your story. I call it a living outline. It is the method I use for Coded Life and I am using it right now for Book 2.
Why the Classic Plot Outline Doesn’t Work for Most Fiction Writers
The classic plot outline whether it is a three-act structure, a beat sheet, or a chapter-by-chapter summary is built on an assumption: that you know your story before you write it.
Some writers do. Some writers can hold the full arc in their head before the first sentence, and the outline is simply the transcription of what they already see. If that is you, this article is not for you. You have already found your method.
But for most fiction writers especially writers of character-driven fantasy and YA, the story is not fully visible at the start. The beginning of a novel is an act of discovery. You are not building a house from blueprints. You are excavating something that is already there, and you do not know exactly what shape it is until you have cleared enough away to see it.
A rigid outline does not help with excavation. It tells you where to dig before you know what you are looking for. And when you find something unexpected a character who is more broken than you planned, a relationship that becomes more important than the plot thread it was supposed to support, the outline becomes an argument against your own instincts.
The result is a specific kind of stuck. Not the stuck of not knowing what happens next. The stuck of knowing what the outline says should happen next, and feeling in your body that it is wrong, and not having permission to ignore it.
The Pantser vs. Planner Problem and the Third Path
The writing community tends to divide writers into two categories. Pantsers write by the seat of their pants no outline, no plan, just the next sentence. Planners outline everything in advance and execute the plan.
Most writers I know fall into neither category cleanly. They need enough structure to feel safe moving forward. But they also need enough freedom to follow the story when it moves somewhere unexpected. They are not pantsers. They are not planners. They are somewhere in between, and neither label fits, and all the advice aimed at one category or the other leaves them feeling like they are doing it wrong.
You are not doing it wrong. You are a pantser-planner, and the method that works for you looks different from what works at either extreme.
The third path is not a compromise between the two extremes. It is a different approach entirely: you plan the emotional arc of your story rather than the plot arc. You know how your character needs to feel at the end of each major movement, and you give yourself the freedom to discover how she gets there.
That is the foundation of the living outline.
What a Living Outline Is
A living outline is built in layers. You start with almost nothing, just the emotional core of your story. Then you add structure as you discover it, scene by scene, draft by draft. The outline grows alongside the novel rather than preceding it.
It has three levels:
Level 1: The Emotional Arc
Before anything else, you answer one question: how does your protagonist change? Not what happens to he, how does she change internally, emotionally, fundamentally? What does she believe at the beginning that she will not believe at the end? What does she carry into the story that she will have to put down before it is over?
This is your anchor. Everything in the outline will connect back to this. When you are lost in the middle of chapter fourteen and you do not know what should happen next, you come back here. The scene that moves your protagonist closer to this change belongs in the novel. The scene that does not, no matter how much you like it, probably does not.
Level 2: The Anchor Points
These are the four to six moments in your story that you know with certainty. Not every scene just the ones that feel fixed. The moment everything changes. The lowest point. The choice she cannot take back. The ending, or the shape of the ending.
You do not need to know how you get between these points. You just need to know they exist. They are the landmarks. Everything else is the road between them.
Level 3: The Scene Layer
This is the only part of the outline that grows scene by scene. Before you write each new scene, you write three things: what happens in the scene, what shifts emotionally for your character, and what decision she makes (even a small one). That is it. You do not plan the scene after that until you are about to write it.
The scene layer never gets written too far ahead. You stay close to the writing, usually no more than three to five scenes forward. This keeps the outline honest. It reflects what the story has actually become, not what you imagined it would be before you started.
How to Build Your Living Outline: Step by Step
Step 1: Write the Emotional Arc in Two Sentences
Complete this: At the beginning of this story, my protagonist believes [X]. By the end, she will have learned at real cost that [Y].
Do not skip the “at real cost” part. It matters. A character arc that does not cost the character something is not an arc, it is a lesson. Stories are not lessons. They are experiences.
Keep this somewhere visible. On a sticky note above your desk, at the top of your outline document, wherever you will see it while you write. It is the one thing in the outline that does not change.
Step 2: Identify Your Anchor Points
Ask yourself: what do I already know happens in this story? Write down every moment you can see clearly not scenes, just moments. The arrival at a new place. The betrayal. The thing she says that she cannot take back. The moment the reader understands what the story was actually about.
You may have two of these. You may have eight. Do not try to force a specific number. Just write what you already know, and arrange them in rough chronological order. These are your anchor points.
If you have fewer than three, that is fine. You will discover more as you write. If you have more than eight, look at each one and ask: is this truly fixed, or is this just one possibility? Release the ones that are possibilities. Keep only the ones that feel inevitable.
Step 3: Fill the Gaps — Loosely
Look at the space between your anchor points. What has to happen, emotionally, to get your character from one to the next? Do not think in plot yet. Think in feeling. She enters this section of the story believing one thing. She exits it having had that belief tested or broken, or confirmed in a way that costs her. What is the experience between those two states?
Write one or two sentences for each gap. Nothing more. You are not planning the scenes yet. You are sketching the emotional movement.
Step 4: Start Writing and Start the Scene Layer
Before you write each scene, add one entry to your scene layer:
- Scene: [What happens – one sentence]
- Emotional shift: [How the character feels differently at the end than at the start]
- Character decision: [What she chooses – even passively, even small]
Then write the scene. After you write it, update the entry if the scene went somewhere different than you planned. The scene layer is a record of what the story is actually doing, not what you intended. Keep it honest.
Step 5: Review the Outline Every 10,000 Words
Every ten thousand words or so – roughly every three to five chapters – read back through your full outline. Check whether your anchor points still feel right. Check whether the emotional arc is still visible. Add new anchor points you have discovered. Remove ones that no longer belong.
This is the moment where the living outline earns its name. It is not static. It changes as the story changes. The only thing that does not change is the emotional arc in Step 1.
The Outline Template: Scene → Emotional Shift → Character Decision
Here is the template I use for each entry in the scene layer. Copy it, adapt it, make it yours.
SCENE #___ Scene: [What happens — one sentence maximum] Emotional shift: [How does the character feel differently at the end of this scene?] Decision: [What does she choose — or refuse to choose?] Notes: [Anything the scene revealed that changes what comes next]
The notes field is important. This is where the living outline learns. When a scene reveals something you did not plan a detail about a secondary character, a shift in the dynamic between two people, a line of dialogue that suddenly tells you something true about the story, you write it here. Then you carry it forward.
How I Use This for Coded Life Book 2
I want to be specific here, because I think it is more useful than being general.
When I started planning Book 2, I had three anchor points. I knew the emotional state my protagonist would be in at the beginning, where Book 1 left her, and what she was carrying. I knew one moment in the middle that felt fixed, a decision she would have to make that I could already feel the weight of. And I knew something about the ending not the final scene, but the emotional quality of it. What I wanted the reader to feel when they closed the book.
That was enough to start. I wrote the emotional arc in two sentences and pinned it above my desk. Then I began writing, and the scene layer grew with it.
The outline I have now looks nothing like what I had at the start. Three of the anchor points have changed. Two new ones appeared in the writing that I could not have planned. The gaps between them have filled in ways I did not predict. But the emotional arc, the two sentences at the top, has not changed once.
That is the part that matters. Everything else is the road. The destination stays fixed.
If you want to watch this process in real time including the moments when the outline breaks and has to be rebuilt, and the decisions about what to keep and what to release that is what the Behind the Scenes subscription is. You would be inside the actual writing of Book 2, one session at a time.
A Note on Getting Stuck
Every writer gets stuck. The living outline does not prevent that. What it does is give you a specific place to return to when it happens.
When you are stuck, go back to your emotional arc. Read the two sentences. Then ask: in the scene where I am stuck, what is my character feeling? Is it moving her toward or away from the change she needs to make? If you cannot answer that question, the scene may not belong in the story or it may need to start somewhere different than you thought.
Stuck is not failure. Stuck is the outline telling you it needs to be updated.
FAQ
How do you outline a novel for the first time?
Start with the emotional arc, one or two sentences describing how your protagonist changes internally by the end of the story. Then identify two or three moments you already know happen, and arrange them in order. That is enough to begin. The rest of the outline grows as you write. You do not need a complete plan before you start; you need enough to move forward with confidence.
What is the difference between a plot outline and a story outline?
A plot outline maps what happens – the sequence of external events. A story outline maps what changes – the internal movement of your characters. Most writing advice focuses on the plot outline, but for character-driven fiction, the story outline is more useful. If you know how your character changes, you can find many different plot paths to get her there. If you only know the plot, you may lose track of why it matters.
How long should a novel outline be?
As long as it needs to be and no longer. A living outline might be one page at the start and twenty pages by the end of a first draft. A rigid outline might be thirty pages before a single scene is written. There is no correct length – only what gives you enough structure to move forward without constraining the story’s ability to become what it needs to be.
Can you outline a novel after you’ve already started writing?
Yes – and often this is the most useful time to do it. If you have already written thirty thousand words, you know things about your story that you did not know at the start. Building an outline from what you have already written, rather than from what you planned, gives you a much more honest picture of what the story is actually doing. Start with the emotional arc of what you have written – not what you intended – and build forward from there.
What is a pantser vs. planner in writing?
A pantser writes without an outline, following the story intuitively as it develops. A planner outlines extensively before writing and follows the outline closely. Most writers fall somewhere between these two approaches – they need some structure to feel confident moving forward, but they also need flexibility to follow the story when it moves somewhere unexpected. The living outline method is designed specifically for this middle ground.
How do you outline a novel with multiple POV characters?
Build a separate emotional arc for each POV character – how does each one change internally by the end of the story? Then identify where their anchor points intersect: the moments where one character’s choice directly affects another’s arc. These intersection points are usually your most important scenes. The scene layer stays the same for each POV; you just track which character’s arc each scene belongs to.
What is a story plot outline?
A story plot outline is a structured plan of the major events in a novel, usually organized by act or chapter. It typically includes the inciting incident, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. For character-driven fiction, the most useful version of a plot outline also maps the internal emotional events alongside the external ones – what changes inside the character at each major turning point, not just what happens around her.
How do you outline a novel without losing creativity?
Keep the outline at the level of emotional truth rather than scene-by-scene prescription. When you plan what your character feels and what she decides, rather than exactly what happens and in what order, you leave room for the story to surprise you. The creativity lives in the how – how she gets from one emotional state to the next. An outline that only answers the what gives the how room to breathe.
How many chapters should a novel outline have?
This depends entirely on the story. Most YA novels run between twenty and forty chapters, but the number of chapters is less important than the emotional movement between them. Rather than planning a fixed chapter count, plan the major movements of your story – the sections between anchor points and let the chapter breaks find their natural places as you write. Chapters end where the tension shifts, not where the word count tells them to.
What do you do when your outline stops working?
Go back to your emotional arc. Read the two sentences that describe how your protagonist changes. Then look at where you are in the story and ask: is this scene or this section moving her toward that change? If it is not, the outline has drifted from the story’s true shape. Do not force the story back to the old outline. Update the outline to reflect what the story has actually become. The emotional arc stays fixed. Everything else is flexible.
One Last Thing
There is no method that works for every writer. This one works for me and it has worked for the writers I have seen struggle with the rigid outline and the blank page equally.
But the only way to know if it works for you is to try it. Write the two sentences of your emotional arc. Find your anchor points. Write the first scene entry. Then write the scene.
The outline will tell you what it needs to be as you go. Trust that. The story knows its shape. You are just learning to read it.
Previous blog posts you will like: